Shop By

Stocking Stuffers

(221 items)

Sort by

Ghost Face® Collectible Horror Rubber Duck

1 Piece(s) #14436110

$24^.99

Quick View

IT: Chapter 2™ Pennywise™ the Clown Collectible Rubber Duck

1 Piece(s) #14436114

$24^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Gremlins™ Evil Stripe Monster Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFWB105

$11^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Gremlins™ Gizmo Full Body Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFWB104

$11^.99

Quick View

3" Gremlins™ Christmas Tree Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFWB100

$13^.99

Quick View

3" Holiday Horrors Gremlins™ Gizmo Metal Full-Color Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MASFWB103

$9^.99

Quick View

4.5 oz. Krampus™ Krampus Image Soap Bar with Peppermint & Pine Scent

1 Piece(s) #MASFLE112

$11^.99

Quick View

4.5 oz. Krampus™ Bell Image Soap Bar with Winter Bloom Scent

1 Piece(s) #MASFLE113

$11^.99

Quick View

4.5 oz. Krampus™ Teddy Image Soap Bar with Balsam & Cedar Scent

1 Piece(s) #MAMCLE102

$15^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Krampus™ Dark Elf Gluggagae (Window Peeper) Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MABXLE106

$11^.99

Quick View

2" Krampus™ Krampus Character Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MABXLE108

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Krampus™ Jingle Bell Ornament Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFLE100

$11^.99

Quick View

3" Holiday Horrors Krampus™ Gingerbread Metal Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MASFLE109

$9^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Gremlins™ Holiday Gizmo Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFWB101

$11^.99

Quick View

3" Holiday Horrors Krampus™ Krampus Metal Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MASFLE108

$9^.99

Quick View

Evil Dead 2™ Necronomicon Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFSC102

$11^.99

Quick View

Light-Up Halloween 1978 Pumpkin Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MATTTI139

Sale

$19^.98

56% OFF

Quick View

Halloween 3: Season of the Witch™ Pumpkin Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFUS103

$11^.99

Quick View

Child’s Play™ Seed of Chucky Glenda Head Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MATGUS118

$24^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Candy Corn™ Jacob Atkins Character Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFCC100

$11^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Misfits Holiday Fiend Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFCM102

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Toxictoons™ Zombie Kook! Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MATTEP109

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Summerween Tiki Mug Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASF103

$11^.99

Quick View

4.5 oz. Trick ’r Treat™ Sam O’ Lantern Soap Bar with Blood Orange Scent

1 Piece(s) #MASFLE114

$11^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Ghostbusters™ No Ghost Symbol Glow-in-the-Dark Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFSP110

$11^.99

Quick View

Goosebumps™ Slappy the Dummy Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFSP124

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Dracula™ Bela Lugosi Dracula Character Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MALESF100

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Halloween™ (1978) Pumpkin Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFTI102

$11^.99

Quick View

3 3/4" Eli Roth’s Haunt™ Vampire & Witch Figures Set

1 Piece(s) #MATTEO107

$24^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Candy Corn™ Dr. Death Monster Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFCC101

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" The Strangers: Prey at Night™ Dollface Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MABXRL104

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Toxictoons™ Witchy! Green Witch Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MATTEP108

$11^.99

Quick View

The Children of the Corn™ Sickle Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFDB100

$11^.99

Quick View

Universal Classic Monsters Curse of the Mummy™ Mummy Mini Bust Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MATTUS164

$22^.99

Quick View

Michael Myers Banister Soap

1 Piece(s) #MATTTI130

$11^.99

Quick View

11 1/2” Ghost Face^® Bling Knife with Rhinestone Costume Accessory

1 Piece(s) #FW90750

$7^.99

Quick View

Holiday Horrors Trick ’r Treat Sam O’ Lantern Pumpkin Metal Full-Color Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MASFLE107

$9^.99

Quick View

Halloween: Resurrection™ Michael Myers Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MABXMF101

$11^.99

Quick View

John Carpenter’s They Live Stay Asleep Glasses Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFUS112

$11^.99

Quick View

Goosebumps™ Stay Out of the Basement Book Cover Magnet

1 Piece(s) #MASFSP104

$14^.99

Quick View

3 1/2" The Twilight Zone™ The Howling Man Vanilla Fear Freshener

1 Piece(s) #MASFCBS108

$3^.99

Quick View

3 1/2" The Twilight Zone™ Mystic Seer Vanilla Fear Freshener

1 Piece(s) #MASFCBS110

$3^.99

Quick View

3 3/4" Eli Roth’s Haunt™ Clown & Devil Figures Set

1 Piece(s) #MATTEO108

$24^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Motörhead Warpig Monster Face Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MABXGM107

$11^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Evil Dead 2™ Evil Ash Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFSC100

$11^.99

Quick View

Child’s Play 2™ Chucky Face Plated Brass Ring

1 Piece(s) #14474728

Starting at

$49^.99

Select Options

3 1/2" Toxictoons™ Every Day is Halloween Vanilla Fear Freshener

Each #MATTEP128

$3^.99

Quick View

3 3/4" Eli Roth’s Haunt™ Ghost & Zombie Figures Set

1 Piece(s) #MATTEO106

$24^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Halloween™ (1978) Judith Myers Tomb Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFTI100

$11^.99

Quick View

1 3/4" Misfits Remember Halloween FIend Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MASFCM101

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Toxictoons™ Boo! Skull Face Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MATTEP101

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Toxictoons™ Trick-or-Treat Bat Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MATTEP106

$11^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Trick or Treat Studios Clown Skinner Full-Color Enamel Pin

1 Piece(s) #MATTBX101

$9^.99

Quick View

1 1/2" Trick or Treat Studios Logo Full-Color Enamel Pin

Each #MATT118

$7^.99

Quick View

2" Ghostbusters™ No Ghost Symbol Full-Color Metal Keychain

1 Piece(s) #MASFSP122

$11^.99

Quick View

G.I. Joe™ Snake Eyes Bust Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MATTHA112

$19^.99

Quick View

Child’s Play™ Chucky Face Sterling Silver Ring

1 Piece(s) #14474725

Starting at

$129^.99

Select Options

3" Holiday Horrors GWAR Balsac Metal Full-Color Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MASFSL102

$9^.99

Quick View

Child’s Play™ Bride of Chucky Tiffany Keychain

1 Piece(s) #MATGUS124

$9^.99

Quick View

Child’s Play™ Seed of Chucky Glen Keychain

1 Piece(s) #MATGUS106

$9^.99

Quick View

American Werewolf in London™ David Kessler Enamel Pin

1 Unit(s) #MASFUS123

$11^.99

Quick View

Child’s Play 2™ Chucky Face Plated Brass Ring - Size 10

1 Piece(s) #MAJAKUS10310

$49^.99

Quick View

Dead Silence™ Billy the Dummy Air Freshener

1 Piece(s) #MASFUS129

$3^.99

Quick View

Child’s Play™ Seed of Chucky Glen Bust Ornament

1 Piece(s) #MATGUS102

$19^.99

Quick View

1 2 3 4